NATIONAL
SOLIDARITY RALLY WITH ISRAEL
U.S.
CAPITOL, WASHINGTON, D.C.
1:00
P.M. EDT
MONDAY,
APRIL 15, 2002
MS.
: It is heartening how many
Christian church groups have made the journey here today.
The values of this rally are universal values.
We welcome a most distinguished religious leader to offer an invocation
for this historic event. Sister
Rose Faring (sp), professor emerita of Seton Hall University, and a founder and
president of the National Christian Leadership Conference for Israel.
(Applause.)
SR. ROSE FARING (sp): Shalom
haverim. Peace, my friends. Indeed,
I stand with you today and always.
When Pope John Paul II stood in Yad Vashem in Israel, he asked us
Catholics, Christians, to remember for a purpose -- remember for a
purpose -- today is such a purpose, therefore I stand here before you to
speak for all Catholics, Christians, when I say we are in solidarity with you,
my presence here signifies that. (Applause.)
Never -- never, never before have Jews needed the support of Christians as Jews
need that support today. Never
again, never again can we abandon Jews. God
has not revoked God's covenant with Jews. God has never revoked God's promise to
Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and I add Sarah, Rachel, Rebecca and Leah. (Cheers; applause.)
And I say to you this morning am Israel hai, now and forever.
MS. :
During our gathering today, prayers and psalms will be offered by
representatives of four major rabbinic organizations of the community.
Reading Psalm 120, please welcome, representing the Reconstructionist
Rabbinical Association, on whose national board he serves, Rabbi Fred Dobb,
Rabbi of Adat Shalom Congregation in Rockville, Maryland.
RABBI FRED DOBB: (Speaks in
Hebrew) -- Psalm 121 -- (Speaks in Hebrew) -- a psalm of ascent. (Speaks in Hebrew.)
I lift up my eyes to the mountains.
(Speaks in Hebrew.) From
where will my help come? (Speaks in Hebrew.)
My help comes from God, maker of heaven and earth, who will not cause
your foot to fail. Your protector
never slumbers. He holds the one
who slumbers not, who never sleeps, the guardian of Israel, the abundant one
preserves you, the watchful one, your shelter, at your right hand a support.
By day the sun will not afflict nor the moonlight by the night.
The vigilant one shall guard you from all evil and will keep you safe.
(Speaks in Hebrew.) May
the holy one guard your going and your coming, now and forever.
Amen.
MS. :
Among the scores of organizations that have made this day possible, the
Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations has played a
lead role in calling for this event and overseeing its organization.
Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome Morton Zuckerman, chairman of the
Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations.
MR. MORTON ZUCKERMAN: Good
afternoon everybody. It's a thrill
to look around at this vast crowd and to be able to say how wonderful it is to
live in a country where everybody can gather across racial and religious and
ethnic lines to express their concerns. We
should convey this to our children, those who are here, and those like my
wonderful little girl, who is four-years-old, who are not here.
And why are we here? We are
here in such great numbers, on such short notice, resonating with passion and
commitment to express two things. One,
to express our solidarity with the president of the United States in America's
struggle against terrorism -- (Cheers) -- and the other is to stand with Israel
in her struggle against terrorists -- (Cheers).
We are here to express our sense of community with Israel, which feels
alone and abandoned. Israel has
joined the mountains of Afghanistan
as the front line in the war against terrorism, and we are here, figuratively,
to be with them in the foxhole that they are in -- (Cheers).
Let us remember why Israel came into being in the 20th century, as a
version, in effect, of the rebuilding of the Temple.
Israel was founded with the simple notion that Jewish powerlessness was
to end -- ending the inability of the Jews to defend themselves.
Jews would now be able to take care of themselves.
They would become self-reliant, and no longer would Jewish destiny be
determined and decided by others.
Does anyone doubt that it is Israel's military strength to date that has
saved so many Jews, that has saved Israel itself, including those who emigrated
to Israel from Russia, from the Middle East, from North Africa, to escape
persecution -- (Cheers) -- and indeed to prevent the emergence of the kind of
evil that has so often victimized the Jews in the past?
Now, Israel as a nation is entitled to use this strength in her
self-defense to the same degree that any individual or any other state would be
entitled to. (Cheers.)
Yet, when Israel takes action to ensure its very survival and that of its
people, it is demanded that Israel act as if it has to win the moral man of the
year award in order just to defend itself.
But Israel deserves support not only when it's a victim, but when it
exercises its legitimate right of self-defense. (Cheers.)
Those nations and their media spokesmen who demand of Israel a standard
of moral behavior that has never been demanded of others, were to follow, put
Israel's existence at risk. They
speak as if the response to terrorism of a civilized nation is the moral
equivalent of the acts of terrorism themselves -- as if there is no difference
between the arsonist and the firefighter, as if terrorism against Israel was not
the follow-up to the rejection of an extraordinarily generous proposal from an
Israeli prime minister that was greeted not with Arab applause but by a
premeditated campaign of violence and terror.
(Cheers.)
America and Israel understand that international approval must not be the
equivalent of a suicide pact. Fortunately,
Americans know and see the difference between good and evil, between Western
values and barbarism, between an island of democracy with a free press and the
rule of law in a region of tyrants and cleptocrats.
That is why, in a CBS poll taken just 10 days ago, 52 percent supported
Israel and only 10 percent supported the Palestinians.
(Cheers.)
This is especially true since November (sic) the 11th, when America and
Israel were seen as allies in America's war against terrorism, and Americans
remember that the Palestinians responded to September 11th by celebrating and
dancing in the streets of Ramallah and Nablus, while Israel lowered its flag and
declared a day of mourning. (Cheers.)
The Palestinians think that today they have the momentum to destroy civil
life in Israel through the impact of their version of
homicide bombings. Every
month, Israel suffers proportionately to what America suffered on September the
11th. In March alone, Israel
experienced the equivalent of over six thousand American dead.
No wonder this is what makes it impossible for Israelis to live their
day-to-day lives, and for any Israeli government to stand by and do nothing.
It is critical to break the Palestinian delusions that terrorism will
destroy normal life in the Jewish state. (Cheers.)
But what Israel is facing on the other side is not a leader who focuses
on education and opportunity, and economic development, and the building of a
state, but rather focuses on the destruction of another state -- Israel.
After a decade of Arafat's administration, the main career opportunities
of the Palestinian Authority lie in strapping on a "Yasser Arafat
belt," filling it with explosives and then wandering into a shopping mall,
a bar mitzvah, a cafe, a pizza parlor, a discotheque, or even more recently into
a Passover dinner, and blowing up as many innocent Jewish civilians as possible.
This was their career path, to gain another $25,000 from Saddam Hussein
for the murderer's jackpot for every successful detonation. And now with the Saudis -- (audio drops) --
hundred-million dollars in a telethon no less, supported by their king
and crown prince -- (cheers; boos) -- to create incentives for more terror.
Israel deserves the world's support because their struggle is not for
their homeland alone, justifiable as it is, but also because they are fighting a
new and horrific form of terrorism that menaces all civilized society.
As our secretary of defense said, the only way to deal with this form of
terrorism was to get them before they get us, to go after them where they are --
(cheers) -- in the understanding that terrorist sanctuaries cannot be allowed to
be inviolable.
This is what Israel is about now -- to prevent the monster of terrorism
from growing to be able to sink its teeth into civilized societies and draw more
blood. America shares these
concerns because these terrorists are the enemies of humanity.
Today, they arouse the Arab street.
Tomorrow, they will cause this street to send new disciples of this
ritual of human slaughter to the west -- (audio drops.)
In 1981, the Israelis destroyed the Iraqi nuclear reactor and were
condemned by many in the world. (Cheers.)
We found out how far-sighted this policy was.
And the youth of Israel will be recognized for fighting and helping --
(inaudible) -- reactor, the Palestinian ritual of -- (inaudible) -- terror by
suicide.
Thank you. (Cheers.)
Now, it is my pleasure to make a special introduction of a special --
(inaudible) -- the minority leader in the House of Representatives,
Representative Dick Gephardt. (Cheers;
applause.) (Inaudible) -- in the great tradition of -- (inaudible) -- of both
major parties -- (inaudible) -- security and the special relationship
between Israel and the United States.
He is a powerful and vocal advocate for working men and women, for health
care, economic justice and strong U.S. leadership over democracy and human
rights across the globe. Just last
week, he completed a meeting of Democratic congressional leadership with
National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice and reaffirmed congressional support
for all steps to ensure Israel's security.
He made a special effort to come here today.
We greatly appreciate it. Please
welcome a very good friend of Israel and of the Jewish community, Congressman
Dick Gephardt. (Cheers.)
REP. DICK GEPHARDT (D-MO): Thank
you very much for giving us the opportunity to be here today.
I want to introduce my colleagues who stand behind me in solidarity
today. Robert Wexler of Florida.
(Cheers.) Peter Deutsch of
Florida. (Cheers.)
Jerry Nadler of New York. (Cheers.)
Jane Harman of California. (Cheers)
Al Wynn of Maryland. (Cheers.)
Steve Rothman of New Jersey. (Cheers.)
Ben Gilman of New York. (Cheers.)
Connie Morella of Maryland. (Cheers.)
Eric Cantor of Virginia. (Cheers.) Brad
Sherman of California. (Cheers.)
Anthony Weiner of New York. (Cheers.)
We stand before you today in solidarity with the people of Israel.
(Cheers.) We are defending a
people, a democracy, and a friend that shares our commitment to universal values
cherished by all.
Since 1948, America has stood with Israel, when Harry Truman rejected the
advice of his staff and formally recognized Israel as a sovereign nation.
(Cheers.) In his memoirs,
Truman said that his decision was in part based on a meeting with Dr. Ezer
Weizmann, who impressed him with a vision of a nation whose ideals endure to
this day. Mr. Truman also said that
he made the decision because it was the right thing to do.
(Cheers.)
Since its birth, Israel has withstood many challenges -- and America has
stood with Israel through each of them. (Cheers.)
As Israel has overcome these challenges, it's become stronger, and our
partnership has become stronger. Israel's
strength and America's leadership have been essential in advancing our common
goals. This is true today more than
ever.
We cannot stand on the sidelines as the prospects for peace are
undermined. (Cheers.)
And we must not waver in our commitment to those -- Israelis and Arabs
alike - who have chosen the path of peace. (Cheers.)
Over the past several months, Israel has endured terrorist attacks
unrelenting in their frequency and severity.
In the past 18 months, more than 450 Israelis have been killed and over
4,000 have been wounded in these attacks. For
a country the size of Israel, these numbers are staggering.
Proportionally, this equates to more than 21,000 American deaths and over
200,000 American injuries. Yet
the Israeli people remain strong. (Cheers.)
And they remain determined to increase their security and pursue a
lasting peace in the region.
The American people are also committed to these goals. As we face some of the most difficult days in Israel's
history, we must remind ourselves of them.
First, to preserve and strengthen Israel's security.
(Cheers.) Second, to help
Israel and its neighbors end the current violence and the threats posed by
terrorism. Third, to resume a
dialogue among those committed to a just and lasting peace for all.
To join us, the Palestinian Authority and other states in the region must
turn unequivocally against terrorism. (Cheers.)
Chairman Arafat has not yet demonstrated a true commitment to peace, and
the consequences have been devastating for Israelis and Palestinians alike. Terrorism must not be supported, condoned, or rewarded as we
work for a resolution to this conflict. (Cheers.)
Four years ago, 50 years after America recognized the State of Israel, I
traveled there to join in the celebrations commemorating its golden anniversary.
Upon arriving at Ben Gurion Airport, I drove directly to the home of Leah
Rabin in Tel Aviv. In a meeting filled with emotion, she recounted the vision of
her husband Yitzhak -- a vision of peace and security for Israel.
He knew that for Israel to endure, its people needed strength.
He knew that for Israel to prosper, its people needed peace. He knew that for Israel to achieve the vision of Ezer
Weizmann, its people needed support.
We will stand with Israel. We
will stand for freedom. And we will
stand for a future that brings peace and prosperity to all the people of the
Middle East. (Cheers.)
God bless all of you, and God bless America and Israel.
(Cheers.)
MS. :
It is our pleasure now to welcome a member of the board of directors of
the National Religious Broadcasters, the popular national talkshow host of
"Janet Parshall's America" and a spokesperson for the Family Research
Council, Janet Parshall. (Cheers.)
MS. JANET PARSHALL: Shalom.
I wish you could see yourselves. This is a spectacular site.
I hope it's carried all over America television.
(Cheers; applause.) And I
hope it's carried on Palestinian television.
(Cheers; applause.) I stand
before you today representing the National Religious Broadcasters. Our chairman, Glenn Plummer is here. We represent millions of Christian broadcasters in this
country. We stand with you now and
forever. (Applause. Cheers.)
When Elijah gathered the people on top Mount Carmel with the prophets of
Baal and Ashtereft (ph), he asked a profound question that should be asked again
today. He said, How long will you
waver between two opinions? The
Hebrew word for waver, and I say this recognizing the esteemed company I am in,
the Hebrew word means to limp, to vacillate.
I am here to tell you today, we Christians and Jews together will not
labor any less in our support of Israel. We
will never limp, we will never wimp, we will never vacillate in our support of
Israel. (Applause.
Cheers.)
Whoever came up with the idea of land for peace has a very interesting
definition of that. Apparently,
to some people's way of thinking, it means giving Israel away one piece at a
time. (Applause. Cheers.)
We will never give up the Golan! (Applause.
Cheers.) We will never
divide Jerusalem! (Applause.
Cheers.) And we will call
Yasser Arafat what Yasser Arafat is: a
terrorist! (Applause. Cheers.) The
time has come for moral clarity. Moral
clarity! We stand together with our
Jewish brothers and sisters, and as God said to Joshua four times in the first
chapter of that book, Stand firm. Be courageous. That is our message from God today. We will stand firm, we will be courageous, and next year in
Jerusalem! (Applause. Cheers.)
God bless us.
Ladies and gentlemen, Robert Goldberg, chairman of the executive
committee of the United Jewish Community which together is a 189- member
federation, is co-sponsoring today's event.
(Applause.)
MR. GOLDBERG: Representing
the Democratic leadership of the Senate of the United States today is the
distinguished senator from Nevada,
Harry Reid -- (applause) -- a master consensus-builder, an effective legislator,
an effective advocate for children, families and workers.
Senator Reid now serves as assistant majority leader of the Senate,
working closely with Majority Leader Tom Daschle, in setting Democratic
priorities for the Senate. A
staunch supporter of Israel, he has particularly focused recently on stopping
the spread of weapons of mass destruction.
Ladies and gentlemen, please join me in welcoming Senator Harry Reid.
(Applause. Cheers.)
SEN. REID: I'm happy to be
here to represent the United States Senate.
We have here today with us Russ Feingold -- (applause) -- Wisconsin; Ron
Wyden, Oregon -- (applause). And
also, showing how bipartisan this issue is, Republican Bob Smith, New Hampshire.
(Applause.)
Shalom. This of course means
peace. It's the focus of our hope.
Salaam means precisely the same thing in Arabic, peace.
Shalom, Salaam, both words, are the sum of all our prayers.
But the prayers and hope and faith on the part of the victims did not
prevent them from being cast into the fire of furnace of the Shoah, the
Holocaust. Nor did it prevent the bitter dose of tragedy that America swallowed
last September 11th.
There is a certain terribly irony in the numbers.
This nation of 280 million people lost 3,000. And when we reacted, as we should and must in our nation's
defense, and to find justice for our victims, the world applauded.
Israel is comprised of about five million citizens, and six million souls
lost in the Holocaust.
I am here today to say loudly and proudly America stands with Israel.
(Applause. Cheers.)
I stand with Israel. (Applause.
Cheers.) The United States Senate
includes members of different faiths, ethnic backgrounds and political
ideologies. But despite our
differences, we have shown our ability to come together for the good of America. Immediately after our country was attacked, Congress rallied
to support the war on terrorism, just as you declare your support for this
effort today. And the presence of
members of Congress demonstrates that we stand with Israel. (Applause. Cheers.)
We stand with Israel, because Israel has been a friend and partner of the
United States. We stand with
Israel, because Israel is a democracy and shares our values.
(Applause.)
Last week, Holocaust Remembrance Day was observed.
And we reaffirmed its message, Never again. (Applause. Cheers.)
Never again will the world fail to see, or hear or speak or act when the
Jewish people are being persecuted or murdered.
We stand with Israel, because we have an obligation to secure the
continuance of a Jewish state.
The tragic events of September 11th were eye-opening. I went to ground zero in New York City and saw the
devastation. I saw the twisted and
destroyed buildings. I spoke with
those who handled twisted and
mutilated bodies. I saw emptiness
where the twin towers once rose to the sky.
I choked on the smoke that continued to billow. I smelled death.
Whether they have visited ground zero, all Americans have gained an
understanding of evil and terror that we had not seen before.
The Israelis though have suffered such violence since the state of Israel
was born more than 50 years ago. Israel
is a small country, and really a small community where it seems everyone knows
each other. So when tragedy
strikes, the loss is intensely felt by all. Israelis have somehow learned to endure attack after attack.
And for most of you terrorism is a normal part of life.
Certainly deadly attacks have occurred frequently.
But for them to be seen as normal is itself a tragedy.
We stand with Israel, because we too mourn the loss of innocent lives.
During the Jewish festival of Passover, 28 Israelis who gathered for a
Seder were butchered -- 28 innocent victims, including children, mothers,
fathers and grandparents; 28 people in a country whose population is small -- 28
deaths in Israel is proportionately equivalent to 1,300 Americans massacred.
And that was just one day in March in Israel.
America experienced a piercing wound on September 11th, physically and
emotionally. We had never before
suffered so much at the hands of terrorists.
The pain is now a part of who we are, and we'll never be the same.
The hurt we felt and continue to feel is the same suffering Israelis have
endured and continued under on the scale that crushes the soul.
We recall other incidents, like the joyous bat mitzvah celebration that
suddenly became a killing field. And
we think of Israelis participating in typical activities, like stopping for a
nosh at the pizzeria, riding a bus to school or to work, enjoying a night at the
disco -- not realizing that they would instead be killed.
But these are the conditions Israelis face.
While we admire Israel's bravery and perseverance in the face of constant
threats, we must not accept a world in which running mate is so commonplace.
Americans do not want to be victims again.
Nor can we expect Israel to stand idle while her citizens are being
slaughtered. (Applause.
Cheers.) Once we identified
those responsible for the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, we
sent our troops to Afghanistan, to bring the terrorists to justice and end their
ability to strike terror again. We
vowed to stamp out evil and to continue our fight as long as necessary. How then can we, or anyone, reasonably ask Israel to allow
terrorists responsible for murdering innocent Israelis to remain free and
continue to plan more attacks? We
can. (Applause.
Cheers.)
Hundreds of Israelis have been killed by suicide bombers. But the total would be even higher if Israel did not have the
ability to protect herself. It's
been estimated that up to 85 percent of planned terrorist attacks against
Israelis have been foiled. So we
must reaffirm our commitment to Israel's security and right to self-
defense. (Applause.
Cheers.) We stand with
Israel, because Israel's enemy, terrorism, is also our enemy.
And the United States has no better ally than Israel in the war on
terrorism. (Applause.
Cheers.)
During the Passover Seder, it is customary to spill a drop of wine, as
each of the plagues visited upon the foes of the Israelites is recited, so as
not to rejoice at others' sufferings. We
stand with the people of Israel who want a safe, peaceful and prosperous future
-- not only for themselves, but also for their neighbors.
I call on all who share our vision and hopes to continue to spread a
message of peace: Shalom, Salaam,
peace! (Applause.
Cheers.)
MR. ZUCKERMAN: -- Major
Owens, congressman of New York, 20 years representing the great state of New
York. Major Owens. (Applause.
Cheers.)
REP. OWENS: Ladies and
gentlemen, again we need your cooperation.
As you can see, the people are still streaming in in what is the largest
demonstration ever in America on behalf of Israel since its founding! (Applause. Cheers.)
This is America standing for Israel!
(Applause. Cheers.)
Unprecedented numbers after five days -- so we ask you please don't push
to the front! And if all the people
in the VIP section would please sit down. Please
sit down so the others can see -- and the sign down -- please? We have a problem that the people are pushing.
So, please, don't put the pressure on the front.
We have people on all the areas across the pool.
We will fill up all the way to the Washington Monument if necessary!
(Applause. Cheers.)
But please -- just please don't push to the front.
MR. ZUCKERMAN: In choosing
his personal representative to be here today, President Bush selected one of
America's preeminent military policy analysts -- one of its premier public
servants, and a tireless champion of close political and defense ties between
Israel and the United States, Undersecretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz.
(Applause. Cheers.)
Over many years as a top official in both the State Department and the
Defense Department, and as the former dean of the Paul Nitze School of Advanced
International Studies at Johns Hopkins University, and as ambassador to
Indonesia, the largest Muslim nation in the world, Dr. Wolfowitz has left his
mark on American foreign policy and defense strategies with a particular
emphasis recently on the nation's war against global terrorism.
Please join me in expressing our enormous appreciation to this
administration for its efforts to enhance Israel's security and to fight global
terrorism, by welcoming our nation's Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz!
(Applause. Cheers.)
MR. WOLFOWITZ: Thank you for
that. Senators, congressmen, all of
you who have joined us here today, President Bush asked me to come, to extend
greetings to each one of you, and to thank you for being here. (Applause. Cheers.)
It is my privilege to represent a president who has rallied the world
against the forces of terror, and to tell you that President Bush is deeply
moved that so many people came here to demonstrate solidarity with Israel and
support for the global war on terrorism. (Applause.
Cheers.)
Like you, like me, the president has been horrified by the scenes of
suffering and carnage we are witnessing in the Middle East.
And so he sent me here today with this simple message, a message to each
of you who rallies here on the steps of this historic building, a building whose
halls have witnessed so many of the great dramas of peace and freedom in
American history. To all of you
here today, President Bush wants you to know that he stands in solidarity with
you. (Applause.
Cheers.)
Private citizens and public officials, Christians, Jews and Muslims,
President Bush joins the words of truth and affirmation that go out to the world
from this place -- words that say terrorism must end.
(Applause. Cheers.)
Hatred of Israel must end. (Applause.
Cheers.) The murder of innocents
must end. (Applause.
Cheers.) And the tomorrow of
Israel's children and the future of Palestine's children, and the future of all
the children of the Middle East must be filled not with fear and death but with
the hope of peace and the expectation of freedom and, yes, with the love that
God enjoins his children to share with one another.
In the words of Malachai, "Have we not all one Father?
Did not one God create us?"
For people who cherish freedom and seek peace, particularly those who do
so in the Middle East, these are difficult times.
But such times can also deepen our understanding of the truth.
This truth we know that the single greatest threat to peace and freedom
in our time is terrorism. And the advance of peace requires the end of terror.
(Applause.) And we know another
truth as well. Israelis -- Israelis
are not the only victims of the violence in the Middle East. Innocent Palestinians are suffering and dying in great
numbers as well. It is critical
that we recognize and acknowledge that fact. But the people of Palestine and
their leaders must also recognize another fact:
That suicide bombers are the single greatest obstacle to ending their
suffering and to realizing the Palestinian state, that the whole world is
prepared to recognize. Peace in the
Middle East is the only way to end the suffering of Palestinians and Israelis,
Arabs and Jews.
To those who champion the cause of an independent Palestine:
We say this -- (inaudible) --
MR. WOLFOWITZ: To those who
champion the cause of an independent Palestine, we say this:
Stopping terror is the most important thing you can do to serve the
Palestinian cause. (Applause.)
Those who blow themselves up to deliberately destroy innocent life are
not suicide bombers -- they are killers. (Applause.
Cheers.) As President Bush
has said, they are not martyrs -- they are murderers. (Applause.
Cheers.) Those who fill the
minds of children with hate, who use the bodies of children as weapons, who
exploit the deaths of the young to further their own power have as their goal
the destruction of peace and freedom.
So this truth we also affirm: that
the future does not belong to the terrorists.
It belongs to those who dream the oldest and noblest dream of all, the
dream of peace among nations. We
gather here today to stand with Israel in this time of trial.
The people of America have always had much in common with the people of
Israel. Like the people of Israel,
we value human life and liberty. We
deplore the deliberate killing of innocents.
And I believe in my heart the majority of Palestinians do as well.
But since September 11th, we Americans have one thing more in common with
Israelis. On that day America was
attacked by suicide bombers. At
that moment every American understood what it was like to live in Jerusalem, or
Netanya or Haifa. And since
September 11th Americans now know why we must fight and win the war on
terrorism. (Applause. Cheers.)
As the president said in his address to the nation, in a single instant
we realized that this would be a decisive decade in the history of liberty; that
we have been called to a unique role in human events.
Rarely, he said, has the world faced a choice more clear or
consequential.
It is my -- (inaudible) -- see up close what the world seems from a
distance: the determination and
leadership of President Bush as he directs the war against terrorism.
(Applause. Cheers.)
It has also been my privilege to help Secretary Rumsfeld as he leads
those who wear our country's uniform. (Applause.
Cheers.) And so today I ask
you to express our gratitude to the brave men and women of America who put their
lives on the line to fight the global war on terror. (Applause.
Cheers.) We salute them.
Together we have now embarked upon a great cause.
In Afghanistan we have driven the Taliban from power and put al Qaeda on
the run. But we cannot stop there. Around
the world we are working to make certain that terrorism finds no safe haven, no
sanctuary, anywhere in the world. And we must confront -- and we must confront what the
president calls the threat of terror on a catastrophic scale, the danger
of terrorist states armed with nuclear, chemical or biological weapons.
No people craves peace more than the Israelis.
(Applause. Cheers.) They
demonstrated that when President Anwar Sadat of Egypt traveled to Israel and
spoke to the Knesset, the first Arab leader to speak directly and respectively
to the Israeli people. That bold
and courageous move was a psychological breakthrough, and the Israeli response
was overwhelming. The result was a
giant step toward peace that has endured to this day.
In that historic speech to the Knesset, Anwar Sadat spoke in words that
are still compelling 25 years later: "Any
life," he said, "any life that is lost in war is a human life, be it
that of an Arab or an Israeli. Innocent
children who are deprived of the care and compassion of their parents are ours.
They are ours, the president of Egypt said, whether they live in Arab
land or in Israel. There are
moments in the lives of nations and peoples, he continued, "when those who
shoulder great responsibilities must have the courage to make decisions that fit
the magnitude of the situation and never to forget that infallibility belongs to
God alone."
Today the terrible suffering on both sides is the real price of war.
President Bush has said Israel faces hard choices of its own. The United
States recognizes, as do the people of Israel, that hard decisions must be made
by both sides to achieve a lasting peace. Peace has a political price, but it is
a price to be paid at the negotiating table, not at the threat of bombs.
(Applause. Cheers.)
As the president said to the Congress three months ago, America will lead
by defending liberty and justice, because they are right and true, and
unchanging to all people everywhere. America
will take the side of brave men and women who advocate these values around the
world, including the Islamic world, because, the president, we have a greater
objective than eliminating threats and containing resentment. We seek a just and
peaceful world beyond the war on terror.
So let me conclude with these words from the psalms. "Let us pray for the peace of Jerusalem.
May those who love you be secure. May there be peace within your walls,
and security within your citadels. and
I will say peace be within you." May
God bless America, may God bless Israel, and may God bless all the peacemakers
in the world. Thank you very much.
(Applause. Cheers.)
MR. ZUCKERMAN: (?)
Ladies and gentlemen, you are part of history.
You all, by being here today, are writing a new page not only for Jewish
history but American history in this massive gathering of support.
(Applause. Cheers.)
As you see, the people, tens of thousands, are still yet to come.
But in order to let all of our speakers be heard, we ask you please not
to -- to refrain at this time -- we will have plenty of opportunity to hear from
you as well. We have people you definitely want to hear from, great leaders of
Israel and America. So we ask you
please cooperate. Hold your
comments. We'll have time in a
little while for all of you to be heard.
MS. CARDIN: Good afternoon.
I am Shoshanna Cardin, past chairman of the Conference of Presidents of
Major American Jewish Organizations. (Applause.)
MR. NAPARSTEK: Good
afternoon. I'm Art Naparstek,
United Jewish Communities, representing 189 federations throughout North
America. (Applause.
Cheers.)
MS. CARDIN: Let me say --
(speaks Hebrew phrase) -- May your strength continue.
May you continue to be united. And
may we all stand solidly with the president on the war against terrorism and the
war against terrorists with Israel. (Applause. Cheers.)
It is my pleasure to introduce an outstanding leader of the U.S. Senate,
a great granddaughter of Polish immigrants, the first woman to be elected to a
statewide office in Maryland, the first woman to serve in the Democratic
leadership of the Senate, and by longevity and wisdom -- and wisdom -- the dean
of the 13 women of the United States Senate today. Senator Barbara Mikulski has been a passionate friend, both
of Israel and the Jewish community. As
a member of the Senate Appropriations Committee on Foreign Operations, she has
been a consistent champion of foreign aid in general, and of aid to Israel and
refugee resettlement in particular for which we thank you.
As a member of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, she is
intimately involved in the war on terrorism.
MR. NAPARSTEK: Please
welcome our dear friend, Senator Barbara Mikulski, a great champion of
democracy, and a friend of Israel and all of America!
(Applause. Cheers.)
SEN. MIKULSKI: Thank you,
and good afternoon. Hello!
I know you're hot. I know you are tired. I
know you made enormous sacrifices to be here, but boy are we glad to see you,
and it's worth every single bit of it! (Applause.
Cheers.)
I am so proud to join you today, to stand in solidarity with the people
of Israel. The people of the United
States and Israel must stand shoulder to shoulder against the war, against
terrorism. And that war against
terrorism must be tenacious, and it must be tireless. I know that we both
suffered terrible losses, and we have absolutely decided to fight against those
who will attack us. (Applause.
Cheers.)
I k now how you feel when you turn to the morning papers, to hear of yet
another homicide bombing on Israel, or yet another attack on a synagogue, in
France, in Argentina. I know you
feel full of grief and full of anger. Well
that's us -- we feel absolutely the same way. (Applause.)
But you know, terrorism just didn't happen.
Young men and women decided to become homicide bombers because they were
incited, and because they were encouraged and because they were funded by those
who know better and should be doing better.
(Applause. Cheers.)
Who is responsible? Arafat
looks the other way when there are textbooks teaching children to hate, allowing
there to be hate radio, and through speeches and demonstrations. But while Arafat is doing that, there are other Arab nations
in the Middle East who institutionalize, legitimatize (sic) and fund homicide
bombings. And we must say no --
have them say no to what they are doing. (Applause.
Cheers.)
I wish Secretary Powell well. I
am glad that President Bush is actively engaged.
It is late, but it is not too late.
And we say to Secretary Powell, as you move around the Middle East,
looking for a cease-fire, looking for a way to begin the negotiations, you must
insist to the Arab nations that they stop the financial reward and the
legitimizing of homicide bombing. (Applause.
Cheers.)
I was on the other side of this Capitol on September 11th.
We concluded that day with the members of Congress singing "God
Bless America." Today I stand on this other side of the Capital with you, in
saying God bless -- God give us peace, God give us security -- God, make sure
that Israel retains itself as a only viable democracy in the Middle East.
God bless you. God bless America! Thanks
for being here!
MS. CARDIN: Please welcome
Michael Bohnen, chairman of the Jewish Council of Public Affairs, the umbrella
organization of 118 Jewish community relations councils, and 17 national
agencies. JCPA, led by its
Washington office, played a critical role in making this gathering possible.
MR. BOHNEN: Thank you.
And thank you all for being here. When I landed in Israel last Tuesday,
just as I stepped off the plane the two-minute siren began in commemoration of
Yom Ha Shoah. I was reminded that
one major difference 60 years after the Shoah that today, Thank God, Israel has
an army to defend itself. (Applause.
Cheers.)
In 1986, the Nobel Prize for Peace was awarded to our next speaker, a man
who wrote about the Shoah with passion and intensity. Elie Wiesel is a symbol of
decency and compassion, a symbol of glorious
triumph of unspeakable adversity. But he is much more than that:
he is a man who renews the Jewish tradition of speaking truth to power;
who takes his campaign for human freedom and dignity to places near and far
where those values are threatened. No
one speaks with greater authority of evil and of violence, and no one speaks of
greater passion of the human and the humane.
Ladies and gentlemen, it is my great honor to present to you Elie Wiesel.
(Applause. Cheers.)
MR. WIESEL: My dear friends,
this day will be remembered in the history of American Jewry. (Applause. Cheers.)
In the years to come, y our children and grandchildren will hear you tell
the story of this gathering, and simply you will then say, "I was
there." (Applause. Cheers.) And I
am saying to you, my friends, today, this place is our place. From near and far, by plane and by train, by bus and by foot,
we have come together here today, young and old, Jew and non-Jew, not only to
proclaim our solidarity with the state of Israel, its citizens and its soldiers,
but also to voice our fervent support of President Bush's war on terrorism.
(Applause. Cheers.)
This time both America and Israel know how real is the threat, and how
ugly the face of the enemy. This is
a battle both nations have to confront. The
only difference is that at this moment Israel fights for her existence.
Still the terror hangs all over us.
We are here to let the Jewish state and its brave beleaguered citizens
and its valiant soldiers know that they are not alone.
(Applause. Cheers.)
When a family celebration is brought to a bloody halt by a suicide bomber
in Jerusalem -- when a joyous Seder meal is turned into a massacre in Netanya,
it is not one Israeli family but the entire family of Israel that makes us weep.
We weep with them and for them. And you know it is not only the Jews who
mourn with them, but also the entire American people and its leadership in the
White House and Congress. We have
learned only too well that whatever happens in Israel could and did happen here.
On September 11th terrorists struck just two blocks from where my son
works in New York. We all know it
could happen just because as easily it happened -- it could happen anywhere --
in London, Paris. Terrorism knows
no borders. And therefore the
opposition to terrorism must know no borders. (Applause.
Cheers.)
Nineteen suicide killers -- 19 suicide killers -- and I beg you, my
friends, don't use the expression from now on "suicide bombers" --
call them "suicide killers." (Applause.
Cheers.) They destroyed not
only 3,000 lives in America, but also the lives of people who loved them and
needed them. And in doing so the
suicide hijackers -- the hijackers changed its political and moral outlook on
this new century. How much more destruction and death?
How many more suicide killers will it take to make the civilized world
understand the fear and the pain and the anguish in which Jews live now in their
ancestral land?
Israel has endured untold murders -- (inaudible) --
saboteurs, infiltrators and six wars.
And remember the PLO and Fatah were created before '67.
(Applause. Cheers.)
But what Israel goes through now, the sorrow of Israel, and unprecedented
-- these murderer suicide killers and their mentors claim that death is their
sole weapon. Well, that is the
wrong weapon, and they will not succeed. If they want to live in peace with
Israel, Israel will respond. One
thing is clear: there is no sacred
cause that justifies the killing of innocent people by suicide bombing.
(Applause. Cheers.)
Thousands of brave and selfless heroes gave their lives defending and
rescuing the innocent victims of terrorism on September 11th and the days since.
God bless the Fire Department of New York! (Applause.
Cheers.) God bless the New
York Police! (Applause. Cheers.)
And God bless the New York -- all those in New York of the Health
Department, the Police Department, who helped the victims survive.
(Applause. Cheers.)
And God bless seven times fold the officers and soldiers and the security
services of Israel. (Applause.
Cheers.) We owe it to them.
We owe it to those who fell and to their memories, to make sure their
sacrifice was not in vain. We owe
it to them to make sure terrorism will never become acceptable as a form of
legitimate political expression. We
owe it to them to finish the job. (Applause.
Cheers.)
MS. :
Please welcome Michael Gelman, the president of the Jewish Federation of
Greater Washington, which has done such an extraordinary job in hosting this
event and making this day a success. (Applause.)
MR. GELMAN: Thank you.
On September 12th, the day after the terrorist attack on our country, my
neighbor and friend, Bill Bennett, said to me, "Now we are all
Israelis." (Applause.)
Bill understood that the war our country will be fighting against
terrorism was the same war Israel has been fighting for years.
He understood that Israel and America are allies in that war and that
America has to stand with Israel.
Since that fateful day in September, Bill has been steadfast in his
support, both orally and in writing. Bill
Bennett has served this country as the former chairman of the National Endowment
of the Humanities, the former U.S. secretary of Education and the former drug
czar, director of the Office of National Drug Control Policy.
He is currently co-director of Empower America and the author and editor
of over 15 books, including "The Book of Virtues." His most recent book, "Why We Fight:
Moral Clarity and the War on Terrorism," was released by Doubleday
last week.
It is my privilege to introduce to you a great friend of Israel, William
J. Bennett. (Applause.)
MR. BENNETT: Thank you,
Michael. I'm Bill Bennett and I'm
from Brooklyn, New York. (Applause.)
I'm a Christian, a Catholic, and it's an honor to be here at an Israel
solidarity rally. (Applause.)
The truth is, this rally is long overdue.
(Applause.) Israel rallied
for us on September 11th. Their
flags were at half-mast. By
contrast, the Palestinian terrorists had their rallies that day, too. They
honked their horns at American destruction.
(Chorus of boos.)
September 11th was a moment of moral clarity.
We saw the face, we felt the hand of evil.
We were not responsible for the attack.
We did not ask for it and we did not seek a war, but the war came.
Israel, of course, has known the hand of evil, too, ever since her
miraculous founding. And she, not
seeking war either, has been fighting terrorism for 54 years. (Applause.)
Moral clarity means nothing less than seeing things for what they truly
are. It requires the understanding
of distinctions, such as the distinction between a democracy and a dictatorship.
(Applause.)
There is a difference, a real and substantial difference, between a
democracy fighting for survival and its opponents fighting to push that
democracy into the sea. (Applause.)
And there's a distinction as well between civilization and barbarism,
between decency and terror. And
when we see things for what they really are, it means the time for moral
equivocation and moral equivalence should be over. (Applause.)
We stand here today to stand with Israel.
Israel, we need to remind some of our countrymen, is not asking us to
fight for it. It is asking only for
the right to be left alone to fight its own war on terrorism.
(Applause.) And if we let
Israel fight her war, we will be the beneficiaries.
(Applause.)
Let us not forget what we owe Israel, who alone, and to the scorn of the
world, girded herself and took out Iraq's nuclear reactor in 1981.
(Applause.) This made the
world a less dangerous place. It also helped us to liberate Kuwait a decade later.
Israel stands as the singular model of democracy in the Middle East.
It has shown the way, and it has done so through untold acts of courage
by Israelis, acts of courage like going to the grocery store, boarding a bus,
attending synagogue. (Applause.)
There's a specter that has grown steadily over the past several decades.
It has not been answered, and hence it has become louder. It is the
specter of anti-Semitism. A Saudi newspaper recently published a story about Jews using
Arab blood for their Purim celebration. Images
of Jews depicted as less than human pervade the Egyptian press.
We are reading reports from the Arab press that speak of "Hitler of
blessed memory," closed quote.
Here in Washington DC, a few blocks away, is the Holocaust Museum.
What we are seeing today, what Israel is feeling today, was
not supposed to happen again. (Applause.)
When you look at Palestinian and other Arab maps of the region, there is
no Israel. When you read the statements of martyrdom from terrorists, you have
to realize that it is no longer just the nation Israel that is targeted; it is
now also the people Israel. And it
must stop. (Applause.)
In sum, I am here as one of tens of millions of Americans who have seen,
in the founding and flourishing of the Jewish state, the hand of the same
beneficent God who attended our own founding and who has guided our fortunes
until now. (Applause.)
Keeping faith with the people of Israel and their still- unfinished
confrontation with evil is, to me, a species of keeping faith with ourselves;
breaking faith, a species of self-negation.
It is exactly that simple and exactly that difficult and exactly that
consequential.
Thank you very much. (Applause.)
MS. :
Ladies and gentlemen, Steven Hoffman, president and chief executive
officer of United Jewish Communities.
MR. HOFFMAN: Some 15 years
ago, many of us gathered in this Mall to express our abiding commitment, in the
face of Premier Mikhail Gorbachev's visit, to freedom for Soviet Jewry.
Among the most electrifying moments of that gathering was when Natan
Sharansky, the long-imprisoned symbol of the Jewish struggle for freedom and
human rights, addressed the gathering.
Since arriving in Israel, Mr. Sharansky has played an increasingly
influential role in Israeli politics, serving several governments as a minister
in the cabinet, and today as deputy prime minister.
Join me in welcoming one of the true heroes of the Jewish people, a hero
of the human spirit, Natan Sharansky. (Applause.)
MR. SHARANSKY: Dear friends,
I am sure many of you remember that sunny day in December of 1987 when we were
here in the largest then rally in the history of Washington. That was the rally of solidarity with Soviet Jewry, for their
right to emigrate, for their right to be free people, for their right to be
Jews, proud Jews. (Applause.)
That demonstration 15 years ago contributed a lot toward -- (inaudible) -- more than 1 million Jews to Israel, but
also to bringing down the Iron Curtain and collapse of evil empire. (Applause.)
The purpose that brings us here today is no less critical for Jewish
survival. We are here because
Jewish people are once again in the struggle with evil.
And once again that evil, if not defeated, will threaten the continued
existence of free people throughout the world.
The United States, under the leadership of President Bush, is waging a
global battle against Islamic terrorism. We
in Israel salute President Bush's determination.
(Applause.) Israel today,
facing savage Palestinian terror on its buses, in the streets, in cafes,
restaurants and hotels, is on the front lines of that very same battle.
Every compromise with Palestinian terror will encourage potential
terrorists everywhere to try and achieve political goals through terror, whether
by detonating explosive belts in shopping malls or by crashing hijacked
airplanes into populated centers.
Dear friends, let me tell you what life is like not after an isolated
terror attack but under prolonged assault of terror.
Terror today in Israel means that when the couples say goodbye to each
other in the morning, they tell each other, "Know that I love you, just in
case I don't come home in the evening."
Terror today means that when you go to celebrate bar mitzvah or the
Passover seder, you go with the knowledge that it can turn into a massacre.
Terror today means that children cannot grow up normally. They are not
allowed to play basketball or soccer outdoors.
Terror means that housewives are afraid to shop, that places of
entertainment are empty, that smiles and laughter are a rare commodity, and that
fear is the constant companion.
But peace of mind and normalcy are unfortunately not the only victims of
Palestinian terror. The human
victims directly hit by Palestinian terror against Israel are not faceless.
They are real men, women and children who have lost their lives, their
limbs, their health and their families to the scourge of terror financed and
directed by Arafat and his accomplices.
Make no mistake about it: Arafat
is at the root of the terror. (Applause.) This
is not just an Israeli contention or claim open to dispute.
There is hard, undeniable evidence, documents signed by Arafat himself,
that place Arafat at the center of the axis of terror that Israel is
confronting.
A few weeks ago, President Bush spoke about the axis of evil threatening
the free world. He mentioned the
countries in Iran, Iraq, Syria. Israel
also faces the axis of evil: Hamas,
Hizbollah, Jihad, Tanzeen, Fattah. And
who is backing them? The same
countries: Iran, Iraq, Syria. And at the heart of that evil, overseeing all and directing
it all, is Yasser Arafat and his accomplices.
(Applause.)
Just two weeks ago, I was at the funeral of my colleague and friend Avi
Aaron (ph) and his two murdered children, blown up by a terrorist bomb in Haifa.
The widow, the mother, was silent during all the ceremony.
But when the three coffins of her husband and her children lowered into
the graves, she screamed in pain and disbelief. (Speaks phrase in Hebrew) --
"It cannot be so. It cannot
happen." But it is happening.
And my friends, it is the duty of the government of Israel, of our
defense force, it is the duty of all of us here today, to make sure that it
stops happening. (Applause.)
Never again -- never again will Jews be murdered without our response,
swift, strong and effective, that targets the murderers and puts an end to
bloodshed.
On the eve of the 54th anniversary of the state of Israel, let this rally
declare in no uncertain terms -- (speaks phrase in Hebrew) -- the people of
Israel live, the state of Israel lives, and we will not compromise on our right
to live in the secure and free Jewish state.
There are those who ask, "But what about Jenin?
And there are also Arab civilians who have been killed in the course of
the war against terror. And isn't
there the so-called violence that both sides are responsible for?"
Dear friends, let me tell you the true story about Jenin. When our army came to Jenin, it was the real autonomy of
terror. Dozens of terrorists went
from there in the last month to kill hundreds and thousands of civilians.
And when we came to the camp, where for 10 years no soldier dared to
enter, we found out that every house is a fortress and that every door and every
car and even dead bodies are booby-trapped and the snipers are shooting from
every window.
And then we had the choice to use the artillery, the tanks, the
airplanes, or to go from house to house, risking the lives of our soldiers but
not risking the lives of civilians. And
we decided to go from house to house, and 23 of our soldiers, 23 of our young
soldiers who just started to live, and veterans who came from (resolve ?)
leaving their families, they fell in order to destroy tons and tons of
ammunition, to arrest dozens of terrorists, but also to save the lives of
hundreds and hundreds of Palestinians.
That is the difference between those who launch the terror and those who
fight the terror. That is the
difference. (Applause.) That is why we cannot accept moral equivalence between
those who see the human lives, human bodies, as shield for the terrorists, and
those for whom human rights are the highest value.
Equating good and evil is an evil itself.
Trying to find a middle ground between good and evil was a policy that we
who have gathered here rejected successfully 15 years ago. Then we knew that in the struggle for release of Soviet Jews,
there should be no compromise. As
with the evil of the communist dictatorship, the evil of terror must be
defeated. Only then, peace can be
achieved. (Applause.)
Real peace, dear friends, real peace depends on us.
If the Jewish people in Israel and the diaspora are united, if we let the
leaders of the free world know that we insist on a peace that is not compromised
with evil and terror, we will succeed. We are united and we will succeed. (Speaks phrase in Hebrew.)
(Applause.)
MS. :
Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome Kenneth J. Bialkin, past president
of the Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations.
MR. BIALKIN: Ladies and
gentlemen, few public figures have captured the heart and soul of a nation as
has our next speaker, Rudy Giuliani. (Applause.)
For several years as mayor, Mr. Giuliani's toughness, which was honed in
his long career fighting crime, has been forcefully turned against those who
threaten both the United States and Israel.
And when the terrible events of September 11 focused the eyes of the
world on New York City, in a new way Rudy Giuliani became a tireless symbol in
the struggle of his beloved city, both to cope with tragedy and to rise above
it. Our nation, New York City,
supporters of Israel, all owe him abiding gratitude for his courageous
leadership.
Please join me in expressing that gratitude now as we welcome Rudy
Giuliani. (Applause.)
MR. GIULIANI: Thank you very
much, Ken. Thank you.
Thank you. We're here -- we're all here today for the same purpose -- to
support America, to support Israel and to support all those who join us in
understanding that we have to end terrorism, we have to end the threat of
terrorism, and we have to make it clear that we're going to stand together to
accomplish that purpose. (Applause.)
I commend our great president, President Bush, and our government for the
determined, the patient, the courageous and the very focused effort to
accomplish that goal over the last seven months. It has truly been inspirational.
Israel is vitally important to America and to all Americans and to all
who agree, and like us, are dedicated to political freedom,
economic freedom, religious freedom, the rule of law and respect for
human rights and human life.
Those five principles define us as Americans.
Together they constitute our beliefs, our philosophy and our principles.
And those five principles bind us inextricably with the state of Israel.
(Applause.)
Israel is an oasis of freedom in a desert of authoritarianism and worse.
It is an outpost of democracy where democracy is unique.
And in all ways, it's America's good friend.
(Applause.)
When American lives were at risk in the Gulf War, it was Israel that
stood with America -- (applause) -- while others turned their backs.
When America was attacked on September 11th in New York, here in
Washington, and in Pennsylvania, attacked for our beliefs, the beliefs we share
with Israel, Israel stood with us shoulder to shoulder while some others refused
to condemn or even tried to shift the blame and celebrate.
We remember that. (Applause.)
To my good friends Prime Minister Sharon and to Prime Minister --
(applause) -- and to Prime Minister Netanyahu, who you will hear from very soon
-- (applause) -- to Natan Sharansky and to my very good friend, Ehud Olmert in
Jerusalem -- (applause) -- I say today that I think of you and I feel for you,
for all parties in Israel.
I remember the attack on my city and I remember your being with me to
help and assist and I remember being with you and Governor Pataki and Mayor
Bloomberg in Jerusalem just a short while ago while we stood with you as you
stood with us to make the same point -- we're not afraid.
We're not going to cower. We
are not going to back down. We are going to stand up for who we are and what we
are. (Applause.)
Let us remember, yes, how important it is that Jerusalem remain the
undivided capital of the state of Israel. (Applause.)
But let us also remember, as these signs demonstrate to those of us of
other religions, Jerusalem is important to us, and our sites, our important
institutions, our churches and mosques, have never been treated as fairly as
they have since Israel has been -- (applause) -- guiding the fate of Jerusalem.
So for all of us, it is important that it stay that way.
All of us yearn for peace, but peace must be based on realism, not
romance. (Applause.)
Peace must be based on security, not terrorism.
(Applause.) The desire for
peace must not overwhelm our common sense.
Otherwise we will fail to achieve peace.
Let's be clear. There is no
moral equivalent between the state of Israel and the Palestinian Authority.
(Applause.) Israel and the
Palestinian Authority are different.